DALAM MAHKAMAH PERSEKUTUAN MALAYSIA

(BIDANG KUASA RAYUAN)

RAYUAN SIVIL NO.02-6-2005 (W)

ANTARA

DATO’ TAN HENG CHEW                                          …      PERAYU

DAN

TAN KIM HOR                                                              …     RESPONDEN

RAYUAN SIVIL NO. 02-8-2005 (W)

ANTARA

1.  TAN CHONG & SONS MOTOR COMPANY SDN. BHD. -   PERAYU-

2.  EDARAN TAN CHONG MOTOR SDN. BHD.                         PERAYU

3.  TAN CHONG MOTOR ASSEMBLIES SDN. BHD.

4.  TAN CHONG TRADING (MALAYSIA) SDN. BHD.

5.  TAN CHONG MOTOR HOLDINGS BERHAD

DAN

TAN KIM HOR                                                              …      RESPONDEN

CORAM:

                                      SITI NORMA YAAKOB, CJ (MALAYA)

                                      STEVE  L.K. SHIM , CJ (SABAH & SARAWAK)

                                      ABDUL HAMID MOHAMAD, FCJ

CONCURRENT JUDGMENT OF

SITI NORMA YAAKOB, CJM

          I associate myself with the reasonings and findings of my brother Judges,  Abdul Hamid Mohamad, FCJ and Steve Shim Lip Kiong, CJSS, and concur that both the appeals be dismissed with half costs to be taxed and be paid by the Appellant and the deposits be paid out to the Respondent to account of his taxed costs in both appeals.

( SITI NORMA YAAKOB )

                                                          CHIEF JUDGE OF MALAYA

                                                                            PUTRAJAYA

Tarikh                   :                   4 Januari, 2006    

Tarikh Sidang        :                  4 Oktober, 2005

Peguamcara Perayu:                  Encik Lim Kim Leong

dalam Rayuan Sivil          Cik Sia Siew Mun

No.02-6-2005(W)                     Cik Wong Yoke Peng

                                                Cik Tan Shin Shin

                                                Cik Rohana bte Ngah

                                                (Tetuan Lim Kian Leong & Co.)

Peguamcara Perayu:                  Encik Wong Chong Wah

dalam Rayuan Sivil          Cik Wong Chee Lin

No.02-8-2005 (W)                    (Tetuan Skrine)

Peguamcara bagi    :                  Dato’ Cecil Abraham

Responden dalam                     Dato’ Shafee Abdullah

Rayuan-Rayuan                        Cik Yee Mei Ken

Sivil No. 02-6-2005 (W)            Encik Sunil Abraham

dan 02-8-2005 (W)          (Tetuan Shearn Delamore & Co.)